Farooq Nadeem Paracha’s work is not creditable because some facts are “flawed” or may be deliberately twisted to fix the situation as required by his thoughts. He writes as an extremist leftist, which reflects his persecution/bigotry. He is not an impartial writer and some time he also distorts/ignores historical facts which does not match with his thoughts. He is a patient fallen in “Zia phobia” and “anti Islamic phobia”. He is unable to point out that Mr. Yousuf Raza Gilani was a member of “Majlis e Shoora” of Gen. Muhammad Zia ul Haq because now this and other “baqiyat” of Zia are with PPP. The “Dawn” does not apply that rules on him which are applied to commentator.