Are the naxals ruining
our country INDIA ??

Yes, I think the naxalits are not a group, which should get any support from the people. They kill people and damage the country. What is the goal of this group? According to their people they want to give each person a similar good life. But how can they reach this goal if they kill people? When the naxals were founded it was a mistake from their former leader. many soldiers died in the fights against this group.
Please notice, that I am not an Indian, but I spend each year at least 2 month in India and have a lot of friends there. No one of them are friends of the naxals.

Hey no i feel u knw half of the truth
and i think naxalite are good b'case
they are working for India's future
they are real INDIANS

I know from the naxalites what I read in the magazines Desh and India Today, beside what my Indian friends told me about them. Why do you think, they are the future of India? But don´t start from their ideas in the time of their foundation in 1967.

They work for real people


temme some points u think which are wrong done by them

I'l try ma best to clear them

b'cause i think they are doing good job

If the naxals want to educate all the children, give proper food and houses to all the people, then they are doing a good job. But as soon as they start to kill rich people, damage their wealth for to reach this goal, then they are doing wrong. Read the reports on them in Desh and India Today you find the informations on them I have. Your politicians didn´t think that the naxalites stay inside the Indian law. All what this people want to do has to be inside the Indian laws.
In their foundation you find the same ideas as we have seen in the papers of the communists. Their rule we had for many years in a part of my country with very bad results.

You tell
why landlordz need soooomuch of land
u knw in china nd japan people give importance to their country first
but here in many parts of ma country like chattisgarh,bihar,gujrat,etc
people are dominating cz dey are proud of their religion
not their country and so poor people are still poor.And this is since many years.
but naxalites are one and they work for India.
And kill only those rich guys who are hopeless,
never donate anything,just are concentrating how to earn looootz of money and also these politicians are like dat only

which country you belong ?
and may I know what are you doing right now ?

I agree with you, that rich landlords or any other rich person has to take part in the social life of India and should spend some of their money to the poor people. But to make them to spend some money by killing some or all of them I didn´t feel right.
I belongs to Germany, but I do research work on Indian music, dance and drama. I spend each year a lot of time in India. I like the country and the people very much and knows to talk Hindi, Bengali and Tamil fluently. Usually the people I meet in India are very kind and friendly,you get friends very easy.But I never met very rich Indians.

Long before I was born they killed in the east part of Germany the rich people and took away all their land. The former leader of this revolution ruled this part of the country, and enjoyed the good life in richness,while the usual people on the street has to work for very less money and were still poor. Now, after 20 years after Germany is united again, the problems created by this leader are not overcome.
By the way, also in a rich country like Germany you find many poor people.India is on the way to get a very rich country,too. Your economy grows up very much. India should have the possibility to include their poor people in a serious way.

Not only naxals, anyone who thinks that shedding blood if innocent people will get them what they want is ruining our india. They are biggest fools who are born to die a dog's death in the end.

Trisha Mathur
http://www.kayasthasangam.com

I agree to you completely Trisha! Violence will never solute any problem. This you see on my reply to the person,who posted the question. This persons opinion in ill minded! I am sure, the Indian government will do their best to improve the peoples situation.

Hey listn
evn soldiers die
bcz of corrpt politicnz bt we call them "shahid"
y cz they r givin their livz for "country"
evn naxltiz die 4 country n u feel they die like a 'dog'?
atlst they help country b killin such crupt politicnz
nt only crupt,those people are blood suckrz
m a studnt f enginerin,2nd sem
i don know which type f naxl s there in ur country n wat they did in..
bt vry soon i l send u those pages f nwzpaprz in which
justic s nt givn 2 sheduld cast peopl(which s nt a smal issue at al)
n hw ur officers sit n watch evrythin like a cowrd

Corrupt politicians are also ruining your Indian country, they are not better than the naxalites.Corruption is a crime against the Indian laws and to kill people is a crime against the Indian law,too. Both of them should have to face the punishment of the Indian law.
The basic idea of the naxalites was all right, but the way they try to do their job is not possible to accept.
If they want to educate the children, give proper food and jobs to the people all is fine. But as soon as they start to kill someone for this, their basic is destroyed.
I know from my Indian friends, that corruption is a big problem in India, but they try to ban it.
You have the law in India to punish the corrupt people as well as the people who like to kill people. Any change has to be done in order to the Indian law. You have the institutions to do all this changes in a way, without the need to kill people. It is much more heroic to stand unarmed in front of armed people, than to kill innocent people.

Hi Anjan,


I read ur article about the naxals. it seems u r so interested in naxals or the way they are doing things. well i would like to share u somthing.

first of all how come u ever tell the fact that they r India's future,real Indians or hero... well i must say "PATHETIC". here am gonna give u ma a\c. read it. think it urself after that.

we all knows that India is developing in a gud way so the people like the naxals can do pretty harm to our development how?.

Here:-

In recent yrz the Nation India is developing like anything so a nation is developing as well as the people. Recently the RAW (external intelligence agency of India) caught Mr "Anthony Shimray" the key official of National socialist Council of Nagalim (NSCN(IM))& his confession revels a lot may be horifying a\c of their intentions. C people who r in naxals have pretty much bad memories in their life from the rich land lords. i do agree in that point,which they are keeping the money & many of the poor people have to suffer but what happens over here is they start to work out this way once the conflict is start their is no going back so they have to keep up with them. what made them to be in a conflict rather than choosing other ways. They believe it will make more effect they start to work agaist their targeted 1s so when a confict is started it soon became a state or nations problem so the state police to the military will come. Then they have to fight against them then only they can work on their targeted 1s so they need more weapons. this is were it all starts to going wrong.On the a\c given by Mr shimray he revels that they got back support from both the Pakistan & China. they offers them MONEY, WEAPONS, MILITARY TRAINNG. in return they need to provide our internal affairs literally they need to destroy us. for the naxals they knows that tey wont get any support from inside so they give GREEN SIGNAL to the helping hands. so both from inside & out side they r developing like a "CANCER" in our nation.

for further refference get the the magazine "OUTLOOK" FEB 7 2011 EDITION.

now u tell me is NAXALISM is "GOOD or BAD"