Casualties of Love: The Long Island Lolita Story (1993) was the third made-for-television movie based on the story of Amy Fisher

Amy Fisher

Amy Elizabeth Fisher is an American woman who became known as "the Long Island Lolita" by the media in 1992, when, at the age of 17, she shot and severely wounded Mary Jo Buttafuoco, the wife of her lover Joey Buttafuoco...

 and Joey Buttafuoco

Joey Buttafuoco

Joseph A. "Joey" Buttafuoco is an auto body shop owner from the USA, notable for his affair with Amy Fisher , who subsequently shot Joey's wife, Mary Jo Buttafuoco , in the face.-Incident:...

, written and directed by John Herzfeld

John Herzfeld

John Herzfeld is an American motion picture and television director, screenwriter, actor and producer. His feature film directing credits include Two of a Kind , 2 Days in the Valley , 15 Minutes and The Death and Life of Bobby Z...

. Alyssa Milano

Alyssa Milano

Alyssa Jayne Milano is an American actress and former singer, known for her childhood role as Samantha Micelli in the sitcom Who's the Boss? and an eight-year stint as Phoebe Halliwell on the series Charmed. She was also a series regular on the original Melrose Place portraying the role of...

 and Jack Scalia

Jack Scalia

Jack Scalia is an American actor. He has had many roles in television series , television movies, and feature films.-Early life:...

 played the main characters in this movie for CBS. The movie aired the same night and time as ABC's movie, though ABC's movie was much higher rated in the TV ratings and critically praised.

Phyllis Lyons, Leo Rossi

Leo Rossi

Leo Rossi is an American actor and writer. He is known for his role as Budd in the 1981 horror film Halloween II and as Turkell from the 1990 horror sequel Maniac Cop 2. His other films include Heart Like a Wheel , River's Edge , The Accused , Relentless and Analyze This...

, and Lawrence Tierney

Lawrence Tierney

Lawrence Tierney was an American actor, known for his many screen portrayals of mobsters and hardened criminals, which mirrored his own frequent brushes with the law....

 played Buttafuoco's relatives.

Cast

• Jack Scalia
  Jack Scalia
  Jack Scalia is an American actor. He has had many roles in television series , television movies, and feature films.-Early life:...
  
   - Joseph 'Joey' Buttafuoco
  Joey Buttafuoco
  Joseph A. "Joey" Buttafuoco is an auto body shop owner from the USA, notable for his affair with Amy Fisher , who subsequently shot Joey's wife, Mary Jo Buttafuoco , in the face.-Incident:...
  
  
• Alyssa Milano
  Alyssa Milano
  Alyssa Jayne Milano is an American actress and former singer, known for her childhood role as Samantha Micelli in the sitcom Who's the Boss? and an eight-year stint as Phoebe Halliwell on the series Charmed. She was also a series regular on the original Melrose Place portraying the role of...
  
   - Amy Fisher
  Amy Fisher
  Amy Elizabeth Fisher is an American woman who became known as "the Long Island Lolita" by the media in 1992, when, at the age of 17, she shot and severely wounded Mary Jo Buttafuoco, the wife of her lover Joey Buttafuoco...
  
  
• Phyllis Lyons - Mary Jo Buttafuoco
• Leo Rossi
  Leo Rossi
  Leo Rossi is an American actor and writer. He is known for his role as Budd in the 1981 horror film Halloween II and as Turkell from the 1990 horror sequel Maniac Cop 2. His other films include Heart Like a Wheel , River's Edge , The Accused , Relentless and Analyze This...
  
   - Bobby Buttafuoco
• J.E. Freeman - Det. Marty Algar
• Peter Van Norden - Joey's Attorney
• Lawrence Tierney
  Lawrence Tierney
  Lawrence Tierney was an American actor, known for his many screen portrayals of mobsters and hardened criminals, which mirrored his own frequent brushes with the law....
  
   - Joey Buttafucco's Father
• Michael Bowen
  Michael Bowen (actor)
  Michael Bowen is an American actor. Films he has appeared in include Jackie Brown, Magnolia, and Less Than Zero. Bowen also had a recurring role as Danny Pickett on the ABC television series, Lost....
  
   - Paul Makely
• Jack Kehler
  Jack Kehler
  Jack Kehler is an actor. He is sometimes credited as Jack Keeler.Jack has appeared in over 60 feature films, including Men in Black II. One of his most memorable performances was in film Love Liza as Denny, an energetic radio control hobbyist trying to help Philip Seymour Hoffman's character come...
  
  - Elliot Fisher