Key

• WC = Walter Camp
  Walter Camp
  Walter Chauncey Camp was an American football player, coach, and sports writer known as the "Father of American Football". With John Heisman, Amos Alonzo Stagg, Pop Warner, Fielding H. Yost, and George Halas, Camp was one of the most accomplished persons in the early history of American football...
  
   published in Collier's Weekly
  Collier's Weekly
  Collier's Weekly was an American magazine founded by Peter Fenelon Collier and published from 1888 to 1957. With the passage of decades, the title was shortened to Collier's....
  
  
• CW = Casper Whitney for Outing magazine.
• GO = George W. Orton
• CS = Charles Sargent in Leslie's Weekly

• Bold = Consensus All-American

Ends

• John Hallowell, Harvard (WC-1; GO-1; CS)
• Dave Campbell, Harvard (WC-1; CS)
• William Smith, Army
• Sherman L. Coy, Yale (WC-2; GO-1)
• Charles Gould, Yale (WC-2)
• Smith, Army (WC-3)
• Henry van Hoevenberg, Jr., Columbia (WC-3)

Tackles

• George S. Stillman
  George S. Stillman
  -External links:...
  
  , Yale (WC-1; CS)
• James Bloomer, Yale (WC-1; GO-1; CS)
• Wallace, Penn (WC-2; GO-1)
• Lawrence, Harvard (WC-2)
• Alexander, Cornell (WC-3)
• Edward Farnsworth, Army (WC-3)

Guards

• Gordon Brown, Yale (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-1; GO-1; CS)
• T. Truxton Hare
  Truxton Hare
  Thomas Truxtun Hare was an American track and field athlete who competed in the hammer throw and All rounder events. He was also an American football player for the University of Pennsylvania from 1897 to 1900. Hare is one of only a handful of men to earn All-American honors during all four years...
  
  , Penn (WC-1; GO-1; CS)
• C. A. Wright, Columbia (WC-2; CS [c])
• Dick Sheldon, Yale (WC-2)
• Teas, Penn (WC-3)
• Belknap, Navy (WC-3)

Centers

• Herman Olcott
  Herman Olcott
  Herman Parker "Bo" Olcott was an American football player and coach. In 1900, he was an All-American center for Yale. From 1902 to 1903, he served as the head football coach at North Carolina, where he compiled an 11–4–3 record. From 1907 to 1912, he coached at New York, where he...
  
  , Yale (WC-1; GO-1)
• Walter E. Bachman
  Walter E. Bachman
  Walter Ellsworth Bachman, Sr. was a college football player and coach. A player at Lafayette College from 1899 until 1901, Bachman developed the "roving center" position for college football. He is regarded as one of the best offensive linemen in Lafayette history...
  
  , Lafayette
• Sargent, Harvard (WC-2)
• Page, Minnesota (WC-3)

Quarterbacks

• Charles Dudley Daly
  Charles Dudley Daly
  Charles Dudley "Charlie" Daly was an American football player and coach, an author, and served in the United States Army during World War I...
  
  , Harvard (WC-2; GO-1; CS)
• William M. Fincke, Yale (WC-1)
• Williams, Iowa (WC-3)

Halfbacks

• Bill Morley
  Bill Morley
  William Raymond "Bill" Morley, Jr. was an American football player and coach and cattle and sheep rancher. Born in New Mexico, he played college football for the University of Michigan and Columbia University and was selected as an All-American in 1900 and 1901. Morley served as the head coach...
  
  , Columbia (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-1; CS)
• George B. Chadwick
  George B. Chadwick
  George Brewster Chadwick was an All-American football player and coach. He played college football for Yale University from 1899 to 1902 and was the head coach of the 1903 Yale football team...
  
  , Yale (WC-1)
• William Finck, Yale
• Raymond Starbuck
  Raymond Starbuck
  Raymond D. Starbuck was an American football player and coach and railroad executive.Born in Fort Ann, New York, and raised in Glen Falls, New York, Starbuck attended Cornell University. He played fullback on the varsity football team in 1899 and 1900. He was captain of the football team in 1899...
  
  , Cornell
• Sarwin, Harvard (WC-2; GO-1)
• Albert Sharpe
  Albert Sharpe (American football)
  Dr. Albert Hayes Sharpe was an All-American football player, coach and athletic director and medical doctor. He played football for Yale University and was selected as a halfback for the 1899 College Football All-America Team. Sharpe was also a star basketball player in the early years of the...
  
  , Yale (WC-3; GO-1)
• Harold Weekes
  Harold Weekes
  Harold Weekes was an American football player. He was elected to the College Football Hall of Fame in 1954....
  
  , Columbia (College Football Hall of Fame) (WC-2; CS)
• Howard R. Reiter
  Howard R. Reiter
  Howard Roland "Bosey" Reiter was an All-American football player, coach and athletic director. He was selected for the 1899 College Football All-America Team and played professional football as a player coach for the Philadelphia Athletics of the first National Football League in 1902...
  
  , Princeton (WC-3)

Fullbacks

• Perry Hale
  Perry Hale
  -Bibliography:***-External links:...
  
  , Yale (WC-1; CS)
• Josiah McCracken
  Josiah McCracken
  Josiah Calvin McCracken nicknamed Joe, was born into a devout Presbyterian family in Lincoln, Tennessee. His earliest known Ulster-Scots ancestors settled in Pennsylvania before the French & Indian War...
  
  , Penn (WC-3; GO-1)
• Cure, Lafayette (WC-2)
• Drufrense, Ronald