1968/69: Sunderland v. West Bromwich Albion (6–3 Aggregate)

1967/68: Burnley v. Coventry City (1–2, 2–0)

1966/67: Sunderland v. Birmingham City (1–0, 1–0)

1965/66: Arsenal v. Sunderland (5–3 Aggregate)

1964/65: Everton v. Arsenal (3–2 Aggregate)

1963/64: Manchester United v. Swindon Town (1–1 and 4–1, 5–2 Aggregate)

1962/63: West Ham United v. Liverpool (1–3, 5–2)

1961/62: Newcastle United v. Wolverhampton Wanderers (2–1 Aggregate)

1960/61: Chelsea v. Everton (5–3 Aggregate)

1959/60: Chelsea v. Preston North End (1–1, 4–1)