Thomas Nipperdey
Encyclopedia
Thomas Nipperdey was a German historian best known for his monumental and exhaustive studies of Germany from 1800 to 1918. As a close albeit critical follower of Leopold von Ranke
's famous ideal of writing "history exactly as it happened," Nipperdey sought comprehensive coverage of every major social political and economic development in Germany, while avoiding partisanship, and rejecting moralistic efforts to discover or disprove roots of Nazism in German history.
While he never finished a book on the post-1918 era, he wrote articles that analyze the phenomena of National Socialism in terms of modernization theory
. He studied the preconditions, processes, and stages of several crises of modernisation in 19th and 20th century Germany, and attempted to interpret the rise of fascism in terms of the interplay and interdependence of modernizing and antimodern forces in society. He argued that Nazism was radically anti-modernist and archaic in its ideology and policy, and yet paradoxically modernist in political style and in the use of political means. For example, it made very effective and original use of newspapers, films, and mass rallies, demonstrating a firm grasp of the latest propaganda techniques. The unintended result was a greater equalization and leveling of German society, even though Nazism rejected the ideal of equality of man and made no effort to end the traditional hierarchical class structure of German society.
Nipperdey generally emphasize broad social forces, and the emphasize the role of the Great Man in history. They sometimes provided an incisive psychological portrait of a major figure for example Kaiser Wilhelm II who he describes as:
The opus starts, "In the beginning was Napoleon" and runs 2500 pages. It contains few footnotes notes, illustrations or tables. Instead it offers a river of text 1.5 million words in all. Nipperdey uses dense description and analysis rather than telling stories and anecdotes. He tries to synthesize a wide range of topics from everyday life, social history. cultural themes monuments, to industry and economics, urbanization, political parties religion high-level diplomacy of the military and warfare. For Nipperdey "the 'colour' of history is grey, grey in all its infinite shades".
The range of topics is suggested by the chapter outline of volume 1:
Leopold von Ranke
Leopold von Ranke was a German historian, considered one of the founders of modern source-based history. Ranke set the standards for much of later historical writing, introducing such ideas as reliance on primary sources , an emphasis on narrative history and especially international politics .-...
's famous ideal of writing "history exactly as it happened," Nipperdey sought comprehensive coverage of every major social political and economic development in Germany, while avoiding partisanship, and rejecting moralistic efforts to discover or disprove roots of Nazism in German history.
Career
Nipperdey was born in Cologne and studied philosophy, history, and German philology in Goettingen University, Cologne University, and Cambridge University in Britain, where he obtained a PhD in 1953 He taught history at Goettingen (1961–63), Karlsruhe (1963–1967), Berlin (1967–1971), and closed out his career at the University of Munich (1971–1992). Besides numerous articles and monographs, he is best known for his multi-volume history of Germany from 1860 to 1918. He also worked in the fields of Reformation history and religious history, as well as in the political history of the 19th and 20th centuries, including the history of German political parties.Ideas
Nipperdey was a persistent opponent of the "critical school" of German historians who saw the underlying feudal and authoritarian political and social structures of the German Empire during the 19th century as paving the way for the triumph of Hitler's National Socialism in 1933. In a series of essays, Nipperdey rejected this view and argued that the 19th century was best seen in its own right.While he never finished a book on the post-1918 era, he wrote articles that analyze the phenomena of National Socialism in terms of modernization theory
Modernization theory
Modernization theory is a theory used to explain the process of modernization within societies. The theory looks at the internal factors of a country while assuming that, with assistance, "traditional" countries can be brought to development in the same manner more developed countries have...
. He studied the preconditions, processes, and stages of several crises of modernisation in 19th and 20th century Germany, and attempted to interpret the rise of fascism in terms of the interplay and interdependence of modernizing and antimodern forces in society. He argued that Nazism was radically anti-modernist and archaic in its ideology and policy, and yet paradoxically modernist in political style and in the use of political means. For example, it made very effective and original use of newspapers, films, and mass rallies, demonstrating a firm grasp of the latest propaganda techniques. The unintended result was a greater equalization and leveling of German society, even though Nazism rejected the ideal of equality of man and made no effort to end the traditional hierarchical class structure of German society.
Nipperdey generally emphasize broad social forces, and the emphasize the role of the Great Man in history. They sometimes provided an incisive psychological portrait of a major figure for example Kaiser Wilhelm II who he describes as:
- "gifted, with a quick understanding, sometimes brilliant, with a taste for the modern,--technology, industry, science--but at the same time superficial, hasty, restless, unable to relax, without any deeper level of seriousness, without any desire for hard work or drive to see things through to the end, without any sense of sobriety, for balance and boundaries, or even for reality and real problems, uncontrollable and scarcely capable of learning from experience, desperate for applause and success,—as Bismarck said early on in his life, he wanted every day to be his birthday—romantic, sentimental and theatrical, unsure and arrogant, with an immeasurably exaggerated self-confidence and desire to show off, a juvenile cadet, who never took the tone of the officers’ mess out of his voice, and brashly wanted to play the part of the supreme warlord, full of panicky fear of a monotonous life without any diversions, and yet aimless, pathological in his hatred against his English mother.".
Books
Nipperdey was best known for the massive three volume history, Deutsche Geschichte 1800-1866: Burgerwelt und starker Staat (1983); Deutsche Geschichte 1866-1918,' vol. 1: Arbeitswelt und Bürgergeist (1990); and Deutsche Geschichte 1866-1918. vol. 2: Machtstaat vor der Demokratie (1992). Only the first volume has been translated into English as Germany from Napoleon to Bismarck, translated by Daniel Nolan (1996).The opus starts, "In the beginning was Napoleon" and runs 2500 pages. It contains few footnotes notes, illustrations or tables. Instead it offers a river of text 1.5 million words in all. Nipperdey uses dense description and analysis rather than telling stories and anecdotes. He tries to synthesize a wide range of topics from everyday life, social history. cultural themes monuments, to industry and economics, urbanization, political parties religion high-level diplomacy of the military and warfare. For Nipperdey "the 'colour' of history is grey, grey in all its infinite shades".
The range of topics is suggested by the chapter outline of volume 1:
- I. The Great Upheaval. 1. The End of Empire: Germany under Napoleon. 2. The Great Reforms. 3. The Great War and a Difficult Peace
- II. Life, Work, Business. 1. Population. 2. Family, Gender, Generations. 3. Everyday Life. 4. Agriculture and Rural Society. 5. Industrialisation. 6. Crafts. 7. The Lower Classes, Factories, Industrial Workers, Social Problems. 8. The Problem of Minorities: the Jews. 9. Bourgeois Society
- III. Restoration and Vormarz, 1815-48. 1. The End of the Reforms: Constitutions and Restoration. 2. The Great Movements. 3. The State and the States. 4. German and European Politics. 5. The Effects of the July Revolution. 6. The Formation and Restructuring of the German Political Parties. 7. Vormarz
- IV. Faith and Knowledge; Education and Art. 1. Religion, Church, De-Christianisation. 2. Education: School and University. 3. The Sciences. 4. Aesthetic Culture: Music, Art and Literature. 5. The Reading Revolution and the Rise of the Press.
Further reading
- Breuilly, J.J. "Telling it as it was? Thomas Nipperdy's history of nineteenth-century Germany" History, Feb 1995, Vol. 80 Issue 258, p59-70
- Evans, Richard J. "ch 3: Nipperdey’s Nineteenth Century", in Evans, Rereading German History: From Unification to Reunification, 1800-1996 (Routledge, 1997) pp 23–42