Warren Sonbert
Encyclopedia
Warren Sonbert was an American experimental film
maker who worked from the late 1960s until his death in 1995.
When he was 17, Sonbert met Gregory Markopoulos
, who loaned him his Bolex
camera, and encouraged Sonbert to make films. They also became lovers for about six months; Sonbert later called Markopoulos his first love.
After he became a filmmaker, he said that his true introduction to cinema was his viewing of Alfred Hitchcock
's Vertigo
when it first opened; totally infatuated, he saw it multiple times, and much later wrote opera and classical music reviews for The Advocate
under the pen name of Scottie Ferguson. When he was 15, he started going to the Bleecker Street Cinema
. One day, during a screening of Potemkin
and L’Avventura, Sonbert found a large manila envelope sitting on the seat next to him, full of issues of Film Culture
, Films in Review, and other film magazines. He took them home, read them, and began seeing even more films, perhaps twelve times a week. Attracted to the work of Howard Hawks
and Alfred Hitchcock
, Sonbert wrote an angry letter to the manager of the Bleecker Street, protesting that their work was almost never shown there. Surprisingly, the manager wrote him a letter back, and as the months went by they became good friends. Sonbert got a job as usher at the Bleecker Street, but he spent most of his time meeting filmmakers through the manager.
Although he shot a couple of 100-foot rolls of 16mm film, Sonbert was still reluctant to begin filmmaking, feeling himself inadequately tutored. To rectify this, upon graduation from high school Sonbert enrolled at New York University to study film. In his second year at NYU, Sonbert made his first 16mm movie, Amphetamine, an early gay-themed filmed centering around the lives of two friends of Sonbert’s who shared a predilection for injecting speed. The film was screened publicly at the Bleecker Street for a number of critics and filmmakers who were enthusiastic in their praise of the film, and Sonbert’s career was truly launched. The film was shot over a weekend in February 1966 at Sonbert’s apartment with borrowed equipment and outdated black and white film stock; the film begins with shots of several young men shooting up amphetamine, talking, laughing and drinking soda. This is followed by a long shot of rippling light (actually footage from an aborted documentary on the denizens on 42nd Street in New York; the film got jammed in the camera during shooting and was considered unusable, until Sonbert realized that it could be employed as a segue for this film), and then a shock cut to two boys passionately kissing, as the camera swoops ecstatically around them, in an homage to the famous 360-degree kiss in Vertigo.
Edited to a soundtrack of the 1960s pop group the Supremes, the total effect was electrifying. Amphetamine was acclaimed by James Stoller in Art Voices magazine as “a heart-stopping film [. . .] completely symptomatic of the film-making revolution [. . .] it seems paradoxically to come to terms with its subject in a way which might be seen as ‘cinematic’ in the essence despite its forthright rejection of much of the apparatus of traditional film-making [. . .] the result is beautiful and pure: behind the bald surface we feel, first, that many inessentials have been cleared away, and then, that the need for them has been cleared away.“
This film was followed by Where Did Our Love Go (shot in June, 1966) a 15-minute color film with a taped soundtrack, which Stoller described in The Village Voice
as “both a valentine and a farewell to a generation, as well as being simply a portrait which is tender, distant, accurate, somewhat high, and sad. In one brief and emblematic image near the end, a group of kids huddles happily in a semicircle on a sofa, neither really touching nor completely apart, and you can feel all the ambiguity and the uncertain liveliness of the teenyboppers in the street, the generation probably no one understands but which Sonbert, in a series of tender and moving moments, has revealed to us. I could watch this film a hundred times; it made me feel old, older than I am, but also it opened my eyes and my heart.”
Next came Hall of Mirrors (shot in October, 1966) a 7 minute film in color and black and white. The film opens with, in Sonbert’s words, “Fredric March
and Florence Eldridge lost in a 1948 hall of mirrors,” the highly-reedited footage taken from An Act of Murder (1948), and then segues into a one reel sequence of poet/artist René Ricard
crying in a dimly lit apartment. The final sequence shows Gerard Malanga
walking through a Lucas Samaras
mirror sculpture in a New York art gallery. The soundtrack consists of two pop songs, “What Becomes of the Broken Hearted?” and “Walk Away Renee,” followed by a portion of Georges Delerue
's score for Jean-Luc Godard
's Contempt
, a film — and score — much beloved by American cinephiles of their era.
Where Did Our Love Go? was, like two of the three sections of Hall of Mirrors, shot in color, and documented his friends going to movies, eating, and shopping for clothes. Sonbert now began to carry the camera with him as he went about, shooting whatever seemed to him to be worth recording. Except for Hall of Mirrors, all of Sonbert’s early films are presented as a succession of largely edited in camera reels, presented with a backdrop of pop music. In this style, he made The Tenth Legion (1966), Truth Serum (shot in April, 1967), The Bad and the Beautiful (shot in October, 1967), and Holiday (shot in February 1968). Though lacking traditional narrative, these films usually had a central subject or a central idea: The Bad and the Beautiful, which depicts ten male-female couples, one per reel, had a kind of hidden code, he later said, in that all 20 characters were either gay or bi. Sonbert had several highly successful shows at the New York Filmmakers' Cinémathèque of these films. Roger Greenspun's review of one marathon show, in the New York Free Press in February 1968, began: "During the last weekend in January the Film Makers' Cinematheque offered a three-and-one-half-hour program consisting of the collected, but not quite complete, works of Warren Sonbert. The program's title, 'Introducing Warren Sonbert,' wasn't really accurate, because several of the films had been shown publicly before. [. . .] Sonbert now has a following, as the overflow crowds at the Cinematheque testify, and it seems more than likely that his films will be shown again. I think that anybody interested in the movies should see them, not because Sonbert is what's happening, but because he is so extraordinarily and consistently good. He is also highly enjoyable, fun to look at, apparently without a message but not without meaning."
Sonbert also had screenings at the Jewish Museum
and the Elgin Theatre
, as well as appearing with his work at the MIT Film Society in Cambridge, Massachusetts. With this money, and a graduation gift from his mother, Warren left the country for Morocco in April 1969; he was to receive family money throughout his life. Before leaving, he withdrew almost his entire work from distribution. It was re-released in the early 1970s.
Around 1968, after having made the two-screen films Connection and Ted and Jessica, now lost, Sonbert stopped using music, and began reediting earlier footage into a long, silent film that, unlike his earlier work, intercut many different kinds of footage taken in many different locales. At the same time, he developed a taste for classical music and opera, something he did not evidence earlier. Surpassing even his earlier films in its spectacular sensuality, his new work was shown both without a title and under the title Tuxedo Theater, as well as others cited by Jonas Mekas in his "Movie Journal" column in The Village Voice in 1970: "'Footage from 1967-1970' is the latest title Warren Sonbert has given his ever-growing, ever-changing film. At earlier screenings it has been known as 'The Bad and the Beautiful' and 'Tonight and Every Night.' I saw it a month ago in London. It was shown in New York, at the Jewish Museum, two Wednesdays ago. By now the short film of 20 minutes has grown to 80 minutes. What it is is a Canto on People and Places. It is the first canto film I know. [. . .]"
These screenings eventually led to Sonbert's first long silent film,
Carriage Trade (1971), which some still consider his masterpiece. Intercutting footage taken on several continents, it began a series of films with similarly radical montage, in which each cut was designed to open up multiple connections and associations. The silent films that followed included Rude Awakening (1976), and Divided Loyalties (1978), Noblesse Oblige (81), A Woman’s Touch (83), The Cup and The Lip (1986), Honor and Obey (1988), In the late 1980s, when the New York Film Festival
opened itself to avant-garde film, Sonbert, taking account of the Lincoln Center audience, began again using music, but now it was often classical music, as in the final section of Friendly Witness (1989).
Sonbert moved to San Francisco—the city where Vertigo was set—in 1970. He enjoyed giving "Vertigo tours" to visiting friends, showing off the film's scenic locations, but he also came to savor, and take pride in, the city's extra-cinematic cultural and social traditions. Soon after moving to San Francisco, he was identifying himself as gay. He traveled frequently to New York, accepting a description of himself as "bi-coastal," and to other parts of the world. Sonbert wrote short film reviews for alternative Bay Area publications, and program notes for the Pacific Film Archives. A cinephile for his entire life, he on occasion presented and spoke on films by other filmmakers whose work he loved, such as Alfred Hitchcock. He shared a taste for the great filmmakers of classical Hollywood with many auteurists, loving the work of Douglas Sirk
(about which he wrote program notes), Vincente Minnelli
, George Cukor
, and Otto Preminger
, among others. Many of his travels were connected with particular opera performances; he saw many of his favorite operas dozens of times. Sonbert had a legendary address book, and in New York would schedule literally dozens of meetings with a variety of friends and acquaintances. He also had many lovers; among the best known was the choreographer Jerome Robbins
. It can be argued that Warren Sonbert's voracious enthusiasm for life, for travel, for all the arts, for friends, and for lovers was reflected in the breathtaking time and space crossing montages of his later works.
Sonbert did have at least two brief teaching stints, at Bard College
in the 1970s and at the School of the Art Institute of Chicago in the late 1980s. He thoroughly enjoyed both, and was deeply appreciated by many students.
A few of Sonbert's admirers prefer his early films, for their wild youthful energy, but most critics acknowledge that the later films, with their complex montages, represent his finest work. The critic Fred Camper, reviewing Sonbert's Rude Awakening in the Soho Weekly News in 1976, wrote: "Disconnected but rich, open and non-assertive: what kind of editing has Sonbert discovered? [. . .] What Sonbert has done, as Brakhage did, though with very different results, is to find a form which never seems to control or over-ride each shot. Connections and possibilities are suggested, but the shot never becomes a piece of a Statement. [. . .] The particular result of Sonbert's form and shooting - the images he uses are fully as important as his editing - is an extraordinary kind of heightened seeing. While his photography is for the most part realistic, I never feel as if I am looking at 'real' objects, or 'real' colors. Instead, shape and color exist in a state of disassociated intensity. Colors, turning in on themselves, glow with an inner light. Often, the image becomes a kind of design in which subject and background are seen as parts of a whole decor, one whose elements seem to change each other by being held within that design."
In the 1990s the Museum of Modern Art
, New York, and the Cinémathèque Ontario presented complete retrospectives of his work together with other films he selected.
In 1999, on the occasion of the Guggenheim Museum's presentation of all of Sonbert's surviving films in restored versions initiated by the Estate Project, Lisa Katzman wrote in the New York Times that "the films of Sonbert's mature period seem to contain multiple worlds. [. . .] In his editing, the images took on a new life; uncoupled from literal meanings and quotidian contexts, they became notes or colors. Through visual puns, metaphors and stunning juxtapositions of color and movement, Sonbert built films in which the connection between shot A and shot B produces the intent of shot C. Like the Russian montage master Dziga Vertov, Sonbert saw film as a language, and his work demands to be read; it is hardly surprising that from early on his films found favor with poets. While it is not always possible to grasp the exact psychological or emotional nuance he had in mind while constructing his 'arguments,' as Sonbert once called his films, their sensual appeal can be overpowering."
, and began working out regularly — suggest he may have had himself tested early. But he kept his status pretty much a secret to most, even as the effects of toxoplasmosis
slurred his speech and affected his cognition, even as he was dying. He did ask his friend and former student, the filmmaker Jeff Scher
, to complete his final film, Whiplash, according to Sonbert's instructions. Warren Sonbert died at his home in San Francisco in 1995. Whiplash received its world premiere at the New York Film Festival
in 1997.
Experimental film
Experimental film or experimental cinema is a type of cinema. Experimental film is an artistic practice relieving both of visual arts and cinema. Its origins can be found in European avant-garde movements of the twenties. Experimental cinema has built its history through the texts of theoreticians...
maker who worked from the late 1960s until his death in 1995.
Early life
Born in 1947 in Brooklyn, New York, Warren described his childhood as quiet and uneventful. His father ran a chemical company in Brooklyn. He had no inclination to make films, and although there was an 8mm camera around the house, he never used it.When he was 17, Sonbert met Gregory Markopoulos
Gregory Markopoulos
Gregory J. Markopoulos was a Greek-American experimental filmmaker. Born in Toledo, Ohio to Greek immigrant parents, Markopoulos began making 8 mm films at an early age. He attended USC Film School in the late 1940s, and went on to become a co-founder — with Jonas Mekas, Shirley Clarke, Stan...
, who loaned him his Bolex
Bolex
Bolex is a Swiss company that manufactures motion picture cameras and lenses, the most notable products of which are in the 16 mm and Super 16 mm formats. The Bolex company was initially founded by Jacques Bogopolsky in 1927. Bolex is derived from his name. He had previously designed cameras for...
camera, and encouraged Sonbert to make films. They also became lovers for about six months; Sonbert later called Markopoulos his first love.
Work
For many, Sonbert was the supreme Romantic diarist of the cinema, in the tradition of Jonas Mekas and others who work within this highly personal genre. His early films were basically diaries: lyrical records of his friends going through their lives, involved in daily occurrences, shot without pre-planning. They were almost always accompanied by rock songs of the period, whose energy added to the power of their rapid editing. The core of Sonbert’s early craft is that he created, without complicated camera choreography, editing, or a pronounced story line, films that produce a heightened emotional state. More than in any other new American filmmaker of the mid- to late 1960s, Sonbert’s people are living and vibrant, reaching out of the screen to enfold the audience in their seductively indolent lives. Sonbert’s early cinema was one of intimacies and personal glimpses of the young in New York. Understated and low key, Sonbert’s films stay with you. As a filmmaker, Sonbert knew instinctively which moments to film, and his glamorous protagonists thus emerge as genuine personalities existing outside the world of the film.After he became a filmmaker, he said that his true introduction to cinema was his viewing of Alfred Hitchcock
Alfred Hitchcock
Sir Alfred Joseph Hitchcock, KBE was a British film director and producer. He pioneered many techniques in the suspense and psychological thriller genres. After a successful career in British cinema in both silent films and early talkies, Hitchcock moved to Hollywood...
's Vertigo
Vertigo (film)
Vertigo is a 1958 psychological thriller film directed by Alfred Hitchcock and starring James Stewart, Kim Novak, and Barbara Bel Geddes. The screenplay was written by Alec Coppel and Samuel A...
when it first opened; totally infatuated, he saw it multiple times, and much later wrote opera and classical music reviews for The Advocate
The Advocate
The Advocate is an American LGBT-interest magazine, printed monthly and available by subscription. The Advocate brand also includes a web site. Both magazine and web site have an editorial focus on news, politics, opinion, and arts and entertainment of interest to LGBT people...
under the pen name of Scottie Ferguson. When he was 15, he started going to the Bleecker Street Cinema
Bleecker Street Cinemas
Bleecker Street Cinema was an American art house movie theater located at 144 Bleecker Street in New York City, New York...
. One day, during a screening of Potemkin
Potemkin
Potemkin is a Russian surname which derives from the word Потёмка Potyomka meaning "dark". It may refer to:People*Prince Grigory Potyomkin, statesman and lover of Catherine the Great...
and L’Avventura, Sonbert found a large manila envelope sitting on the seat next to him, full of issues of Film Culture
Film Culture
Film Culture was an American film magazine started by Adolfas Mekas and his brother Jonas Mekas in 1954, and is now defunct. It is best known for exploring the avant-garde cinema in depth, but also published articles on all aspects of cinema, including Hollywood films.Past contributors include...
, Films in Review, and other film magazines. He took them home, read them, and began seeing even more films, perhaps twelve times a week. Attracted to the work of Howard Hawks
Howard Hawks
Howard Winchester Hawks was an American film director, producer and screenwriter of the classic Hollywood era...
and Alfred Hitchcock
Alfred Hitchcock
Sir Alfred Joseph Hitchcock, KBE was a British film director and producer. He pioneered many techniques in the suspense and psychological thriller genres. After a successful career in British cinema in both silent films and early talkies, Hitchcock moved to Hollywood...
, Sonbert wrote an angry letter to the manager of the Bleecker Street, protesting that their work was almost never shown there. Surprisingly, the manager wrote him a letter back, and as the months went by they became good friends. Sonbert got a job as usher at the Bleecker Street, but he spent most of his time meeting filmmakers through the manager.
Although he shot a couple of 100-foot rolls of 16mm film, Sonbert was still reluctant to begin filmmaking, feeling himself inadequately tutored. To rectify this, upon graduation from high school Sonbert enrolled at New York University to study film. In his second year at NYU, Sonbert made his first 16mm movie, Amphetamine, an early gay-themed filmed centering around the lives of two friends of Sonbert’s who shared a predilection for injecting speed. The film was screened publicly at the Bleecker Street for a number of critics and filmmakers who were enthusiastic in their praise of the film, and Sonbert’s career was truly launched. The film was shot over a weekend in February 1966 at Sonbert’s apartment with borrowed equipment and outdated black and white film stock; the film begins with shots of several young men shooting up amphetamine, talking, laughing and drinking soda. This is followed by a long shot of rippling light (actually footage from an aborted documentary on the denizens on 42nd Street in New York; the film got jammed in the camera during shooting and was considered unusable, until Sonbert realized that it could be employed as a segue for this film), and then a shock cut to two boys passionately kissing, as the camera swoops ecstatically around them, in an homage to the famous 360-degree kiss in Vertigo.
Edited to a soundtrack of the 1960s pop group the Supremes, the total effect was electrifying. Amphetamine was acclaimed by James Stoller in Art Voices magazine as “a heart-stopping film [. . .] completely symptomatic of the film-making revolution [. . .] it seems paradoxically to come to terms with its subject in a way which might be seen as ‘cinematic’ in the essence despite its forthright rejection of much of the apparatus of traditional film-making [. . .] the result is beautiful and pure: behind the bald surface we feel, first, that many inessentials have been cleared away, and then, that the need for them has been cleared away.“
This film was followed by Where Did Our Love Go (shot in June, 1966) a 15-minute color film with a taped soundtrack, which Stoller described in The Village Voice
The Village Voice
The Village Voice is a free weekly newspaper and news and features website in New York City that features investigative articles, analysis of current affairs and culture, arts and music coverage, and events listings for New York City...
as “both a valentine and a farewell to a generation, as well as being simply a portrait which is tender, distant, accurate, somewhat high, and sad. In one brief and emblematic image near the end, a group of kids huddles happily in a semicircle on a sofa, neither really touching nor completely apart, and you can feel all the ambiguity and the uncertain liveliness of the teenyboppers in the street, the generation probably no one understands but which Sonbert, in a series of tender and moving moments, has revealed to us. I could watch this film a hundred times; it made me feel old, older than I am, but also it opened my eyes and my heart.”
Next came Hall of Mirrors (shot in October, 1966) a 7 minute film in color and black and white. The film opens with, in Sonbert’s words, “Fredric March
Fredric March
Fredric March was an American stage and film actor. He won the Academy Award for Best Actor in 1932 for Dr. Jekyll and Mr...
and Florence Eldridge lost in a 1948 hall of mirrors,” the highly-reedited footage taken from An Act of Murder (1948), and then segues into a one reel sequence of poet/artist René Ricard
René Ricard
René Ricard is an American poet, art critic and painter.Ricard grew up in Acushnet, Massachusetts. As a young teenager he ran away to Boston and assimilated into the literary scene of the city. By age eighteen he’d moved to New York City, where he became a protege of Andy Warhol...
crying in a dimly lit apartment. The final sequence shows Gerard Malanga
Gerard Malanga
Gerard Joseph Malanga is an American poet, photographer, filmmaker, curator and archivist.-Early life:Born in the Bronx, New York, Malanga graduated from the School of Industrial Art in Manhattan and attended Wagner College on Staten Island...
walking through a Lucas Samaras
Lucas Samaras
Lucas Samaras , is an artist, born in Kastoria, Greece. He studied at Rutgers University on a scholarship, where he met Allan Kaprow and George Segal. While at Rutgers, he joined Gamma Sigma . He participated in Kaprow's "Happenings," and posed for Segal's plaster sculptures...
mirror sculpture in a New York art gallery. The soundtrack consists of two pop songs, “What Becomes of the Broken Hearted?” and “Walk Away Renee,” followed by a portion of Georges Delerue
Georges Delerue
Georges Delerue , was a French film composer who composed over 350 scores for cinema and television. He won numerous important awards including Rome Prize , Emmy Award , Genie Award , ACE Award and Academy Award for Best Original Score in 1979 for A...
's score for Jean-Luc Godard
Jean-Luc Godard
Jean-Luc Godard is a French-Swiss film director, screenwriter and film critic. He is often identified with the 1960s French film movement, French Nouvelle Vague, or "New Wave"....
's Contempt
Contempt (film)
Contempt is a 1963 film directed by Jean-Luc Godard, based on the Italian novel Il disprezzo by Alberto Moravia. It stars Brigitte Bardot.-Plot:...
, a film — and score — much beloved by American cinephiles of their era.
Where Did Our Love Go? was, like two of the three sections of Hall of Mirrors, shot in color, and documented his friends going to movies, eating, and shopping for clothes. Sonbert now began to carry the camera with him as he went about, shooting whatever seemed to him to be worth recording. Except for Hall of Mirrors, all of Sonbert’s early films are presented as a succession of largely edited in camera reels, presented with a backdrop of pop music. In this style, he made The Tenth Legion (1966), Truth Serum (shot in April, 1967), The Bad and the Beautiful (shot in October, 1967), and Holiday (shot in February 1968). Though lacking traditional narrative, these films usually had a central subject or a central idea: The Bad and the Beautiful, which depicts ten male-female couples, one per reel, had a kind of hidden code, he later said, in that all 20 characters were either gay or bi. Sonbert had several highly successful shows at the New York Filmmakers' Cinémathèque of these films. Roger Greenspun's review of one marathon show, in the New York Free Press in February 1968, began: "During the last weekend in January the Film Makers' Cinematheque offered a three-and-one-half-hour program consisting of the collected, but not quite complete, works of Warren Sonbert. The program's title, 'Introducing Warren Sonbert,' wasn't really accurate, because several of the films had been shown publicly before. [. . .] Sonbert now has a following, as the overflow crowds at the Cinematheque testify, and it seems more than likely that his films will be shown again. I think that anybody interested in the movies should see them, not because Sonbert is what's happening, but because he is so extraordinarily and consistently good. He is also highly enjoyable, fun to look at, apparently without a message but not without meaning."
Sonbert also had screenings at the Jewish Museum
Jewish Museum (New York)
The Jewish Museum of New York, an art museum and repository of cultural artifacts, is the leading Jewish museum in the United States. With over 26,000 objects, it contains the largest collection of art and Jewish culture outside of museums in Israel. The museum is housed at 1109 Fifth Avenue, in...
and the Elgin Theatre
Elgin Theater
The Elgin Theater opened in 1942 on Eighth Avenue in New York City. It was designed in the Art Moderne style by Simon Zelnik and was a popular movie house for decades seating 600. It served as a home to cult films and revivals and, later in its career, as an adult theater. In 1978 the community...
, as well as appearing with his work at the MIT Film Society in Cambridge, Massachusetts. With this money, and a graduation gift from his mother, Warren left the country for Morocco in April 1969; he was to receive family money throughout his life. Before leaving, he withdrew almost his entire work from distribution. It was re-released in the early 1970s.
Around 1968, after having made the two-screen films Connection and Ted and Jessica, now lost, Sonbert stopped using music, and began reediting earlier footage into a long, silent film that, unlike his earlier work, intercut many different kinds of footage taken in many different locales. At the same time, he developed a taste for classical music and opera, something he did not evidence earlier. Surpassing even his earlier films in its spectacular sensuality, his new work was shown both without a title and under the title Tuxedo Theater, as well as others cited by Jonas Mekas in his "Movie Journal" column in The Village Voice in 1970: "'Footage from 1967-1970' is the latest title Warren Sonbert has given his ever-growing, ever-changing film. At earlier screenings it has been known as 'The Bad and the Beautiful' and 'Tonight and Every Night.' I saw it a month ago in London. It was shown in New York, at the Jewish Museum, two Wednesdays ago. By now the short film of 20 minutes has grown to 80 minutes. What it is is a Canto on People and Places. It is the first canto film I know. [. . .]"
These screenings eventually led to Sonbert's first long silent film,
Carriage Trade (1971), which some still consider his masterpiece. Intercutting footage taken on several continents, it began a series of films with similarly radical montage, in which each cut was designed to open up multiple connections and associations. The silent films that followed included Rude Awakening (1976), and Divided Loyalties (1978), Noblesse Oblige (81), A Woman’s Touch (83), The Cup and The Lip (1986), Honor and Obey (1988), In the late 1980s, when the New York Film Festival
New York Film Festival
The New York Film Festival has been a major film festival since it began in 1963 in New York. The films are selected by the Film Society of Lincoln Center...
opened itself to avant-garde film, Sonbert, taking account of the Lincoln Center audience, began again using music, but now it was often classical music, as in the final section of Friendly Witness (1989).
Sonbert moved to San Francisco—the city where Vertigo was set—in 1970. He enjoyed giving "Vertigo tours" to visiting friends, showing off the film's scenic locations, but he also came to savor, and take pride in, the city's extra-cinematic cultural and social traditions. Soon after moving to San Francisco, he was identifying himself as gay. He traveled frequently to New York, accepting a description of himself as "bi-coastal," and to other parts of the world. Sonbert wrote short film reviews for alternative Bay Area publications, and program notes for the Pacific Film Archives. A cinephile for his entire life, he on occasion presented and spoke on films by other filmmakers whose work he loved, such as Alfred Hitchcock. He shared a taste for the great filmmakers of classical Hollywood with many auteurists, loving the work of Douglas Sirk
Douglas Sirk
Douglas Sirk was a Danish-German film director best known for his work in Hollywood melodramas in the 1950s.-Life and work:...
(about which he wrote program notes), Vincente Minnelli
Vincente Minnelli
Vincente Minnelli was an American stage director and film director, famous for directing such classic movie musicals as Meet Me in St. Louis, The Band Wagon, and An American in Paris. In addition to having directed some of the most famous and well-remembered musicals of his time, Minnelli made...
, George Cukor
George Cukor
George Dewey Cukor was an American film director. He mainly concentrated on comedies and literary adaptations. His career flourished at RKO and later MGM, where he directed What Price Hollywood? , A Bill of Divorcement , Dinner at Eight , Little Women , David Copperfield , Romeo and Juliet and...
, and Otto Preminger
Otto Preminger
Otto Ludwig Preminger was an Austro–Hungarian-American theatre and film director.After moving from the theatre to Hollywood, he directed over 35 feature films in a five-decade career. He rose to prominence for stylish film noir mysteries such as Laura and Fallen Angel...
, among others. Many of his travels were connected with particular opera performances; he saw many of his favorite operas dozens of times. Sonbert had a legendary address book, and in New York would schedule literally dozens of meetings with a variety of friends and acquaintances. He also had many lovers; among the best known was the choreographer Jerome Robbins
Jerome Robbins
Jerome Robbins was an American theater producer, director, and choreographer known primarily for Broadway Theater and Ballet/Dance, but who also occasionally directed films and directed/produced for television. His work has included everything from classical ballet to contemporary musical theater...
. It can be argued that Warren Sonbert's voracious enthusiasm for life, for travel, for all the arts, for friends, and for lovers was reflected in the breathtaking time and space crossing montages of his later works.
Sonbert did have at least two brief teaching stints, at Bard College
Bard College
Bard College, founded in 1860 as "St. Stephen's College", is a small four-year liberal arts college located in Annandale-on-Hudson, New York.-Location:...
in the 1970s and at the School of the Art Institute of Chicago in the late 1980s. He thoroughly enjoyed both, and was deeply appreciated by many students.
A few of Sonbert's admirers prefer his early films, for their wild youthful energy, but most critics acknowledge that the later films, with their complex montages, represent his finest work. The critic Fred Camper, reviewing Sonbert's Rude Awakening in the Soho Weekly News in 1976, wrote: "Disconnected but rich, open and non-assertive: what kind of editing has Sonbert discovered? [. . .] What Sonbert has done, as Brakhage did, though with very different results, is to find a form which never seems to control or over-ride each shot. Connections and possibilities are suggested, but the shot never becomes a piece of a Statement. [. . .] The particular result of Sonbert's form and shooting - the images he uses are fully as important as his editing - is an extraordinary kind of heightened seeing. While his photography is for the most part realistic, I never feel as if I am looking at 'real' objects, or 'real' colors. Instead, shape and color exist in a state of disassociated intensity. Colors, turning in on themselves, glow with an inner light. Often, the image becomes a kind of design in which subject and background are seen as parts of a whole decor, one whose elements seem to change each other by being held within that design."
In the 1990s the Museum of Modern Art
Museum of Modern Art
The Museum of Modern Art is an art museum in Midtown Manhattan in New York City, on 53rd Street, between Fifth and Sixth Avenues. It has been important in developing and collecting modernist art, and is often identified as the most influential museum of modern art in the world...
, New York, and the Cinémathèque Ontario presented complete retrospectives of his work together with other films he selected.
In 1999, on the occasion of the Guggenheim Museum's presentation of all of Sonbert's surviving films in restored versions initiated by the Estate Project, Lisa Katzman wrote in the New York Times that "the films of Sonbert's mature period seem to contain multiple worlds. [. . .] In his editing, the images took on a new life; uncoupled from literal meanings and quotidian contexts, they became notes or colors. Through visual puns, metaphors and stunning juxtapositions of color and movement, Sonbert built films in which the connection between shot A and shot B produces the intent of shot C. Like the Russian montage master Dziga Vertov, Sonbert saw film as a language, and his work demands to be read; it is hardly surprising that from early on his films found favor with poets. While it is not always possible to grasp the exact psychological or emotional nuance he had in mind while constructing his 'arguments,' as Sonbert once called his films, their sensual appeal can be overpowering."
Death
It is not known when Sonbert first learned he was HIV-positive, but changes in his habits in the late 1980s — he stopped smokingSmoking
Smoking is a practice in which a substance, most commonly tobacco or cannabis, is burned and the smoke is tasted or inhaled. This is primarily practised as a route of administration for recreational drug use, as combustion releases the active substances in drugs such as nicotine and makes them...
, and began working out regularly — suggest he may have had himself tested early. But he kept his status pretty much a secret to most, even as the effects of toxoplasmosis
Toxoplasmosis
Toxoplasmosis is a parasitic disease caused by the protozoan Toxoplasma gondii. The parasite infects most genera of warm-blooded animals, including humans, but the primary host is the felid family. Animals are infected by eating infected meat, by ingestion of feces of a cat that has itself...
slurred his speech and affected his cognition, even as he was dying. He did ask his friend and former student, the filmmaker Jeff Scher
Jeff Scher
Jeff Scher is a New York-based filmmaker, animator and painter. He was born Jeffery Noyes Scher, on December 24, 1954. Scher graduated from Bard College in 1976. He is married to Bonnie Siegler and they currently live in Brooklyn with their two children...
, to complete his final film, Whiplash, according to Sonbert's instructions. Warren Sonbert died at his home in San Francisco in 1995. Whiplash received its world premiere at the New York Film Festival
New York Film Festival
The New York Film Festival has been a major film festival since it began in 1963 in New York. The films are selected by the Film Society of Lincoln Center...
in 1997.