Felix Ziegel
Encyclopedia
Felix Yurievich Ziegel was a Soviet researcher, Doctor of Science and docent
of Cosmology
at the Moscow Aviation Institute
, author of more than 40 popular books on astronomy
and space exploration, generally regarded as a founder of Russia
n ufology
. Ziegel, co-organizer of the first ever officially approved Soviet UFO studying group, became an overnight sensation when, on November 10, 1967, speaking on the Soviet central television, he made an extensive report on the UFO sightings registered in the USSR and encouraged viewers to send him and his colleagues first-hand accounts of their observations, which resulted in barrage of letters and reports. Having lost the final of his many battles with detractors in 1976, Ziegel continued his studies unofficially. He died in November 1988, 17 massive volumes of his vast research legacy remaining in his daughter's archives, unpublished.
. Ziegel often spoke (as his daughter wrote in her memoirs) of how he’d begin his future autobiography with the words: "I was sentenced to death before I was even born". Indeed, in March 1920 Yury Ziegel’s 22-year old wife, Nadezhda Platonovna, was on the Cheka
’s death row, waiting to be put before the firing squad for alleged ‘counter-revolutionary activities’. In the unlikeliest turn of events (as her grand-daughter later wrote) the sight of a 'doomed young beauty in her last days of pregnancy' made so disturbing an effect on a senior investigator officer that what he did was promptly open the door and let her go. One week after her miraculous release Nadezhda Ziegel gave birth to her son. The parents called him Felix, although not after Dzerzhinsky, the infamous ‘iron man’ of the early Soviet revolutionary justice, as some of the family’s friends half-seriously suggested. It was Prince Felix Yusupov
, the man behind the notorious Rasputin murder, whom husband and wife hero-worshipped, praising his ‘patriotism and unique courage’.
Felix Ziegel, born a weak and sickly child, was sent to the family's countryside dacha
in Tarusa
to be there literally milked back to life. It was here in Tarusa that a six year old constructed his first primitive telescope
and started his first journal of astronomical observations. Regardless of the post-1917 hardships, Yuri Ziegel managed to give his son fine education, both technical and humanitarian. Young Felix, apart from being a fanatical astronomy enthusiast, showed deep interest in (and later - academic level knowledge of) history, philosophy
, Russian Orthodox Church
architecture and theology
, the family being a very religious one. In fact, influenced by his spiritual tutor, Alexandr Vvedensky
, whose sermons he attended regularly, Felix seriously considered the possibility of devoting himself to religion. Love for astronomy prevailed, though, and in 1938 he joined the Moscow University’s Mekhmat (Mechanics & mathematics) faculty.
Two years earlier 16 year old Felix Ziegel took part in his first ever scientific expedition: along with the team of senior scientists he traveled to Kazahstan to observe the total eclipse
of the Sun
. It was there that Ziegel - in the case of rare coincidence - got acquainted with a member of an US expedition camped nearside. The name of the American was Donald Howard Menzel
, the one whose book some years later would change his whole life.
In 1939 Felix Ziegel, a 2nd year student, was expelled from the University, the reason being his father’s arrest for allegedly plotting the destruction a factory in Tambov
. It soon transpired that the anonymous report was compiled by a neighbour, motivated by the prospect of moving into the jailed man’s flat. Yuri Ziegel was freed, but not until he spent two years in prison. According to Tatyana, his grand-daughter, Ziegel-senior returned a physically and morally broken man. His leg had to be amputated – a direct consequence of so-called zhuravl (the Crane) torture which involved causing a prisoner to stand on one leg during the interrogation.
In 1941, as the war broke out, Ziegels were deported to Alma-Ata. That was taken as a kind of favour, almost, since Felix, as an ethnic German, might have ended up easily in a labour camp or the much feared shtrafbat ranks. Soon he even managed to return to the University which he was graduated from in 1945. The same year his first book "Eclipses of the Moon" was published. In 1948 after three years’ work in the USSR Academy of Science F. Ziegel has got his Doctor of Sciences' Сanditate degree (in astronomy) and started lecturing in Moscow institutes.
In the late 1940s Ziegel made his debut as a public lecturer, speaking mostly in Moscow's Geodesic institute and The Planetarium, to a hugely favourable popular response. Ziegel's Life on Mars
and Tunguska
spoken-word shows were all-round favourites; one-kilometer queus of avid ticket-buyers stretched out to the venues. Ziegel’s lectures were staged in the manner of modernist theater pieces. The Tunguska show, based on the Alexander Kazantsev
’s sci-fi short story Vzryv (The Blast) had a soldier protagonist played by a professional actor; the latter sauntered all around the place, theoreticising about how Tunguska disaster might have been the result of an atom bomb explosion akin to that of Hiroshima
or an alien spacecraft crash, enthralled audience members gradually being involved into a discussion.
Indeed, it was Ziegel who put forward the first ever mathematically justified hypothesis for Tunguska blast having been the result of an alien spacecraft crash (which, according to the author, made a curve-like maneuver 600 kilometers in diameter before exploding in the air). The concept jarred with the official ‘meteorite theory’ but a decade later the evidence was found proving the object indeed went off in the air, without contacting the Earth. The discovery was a result of numerous expeditions to the region in the 1960s made by enthusiasts who, in their own turn, cited early Ziegel's lectures as an original inspiration.
In 1963 Ziegel, now a co-author (with V. P. Burdakov) of the first ever Soviet university textbook on cosmonautics and space exploration became the astronomy docent in the Moscow Aviation Institute
. The same year he read Donald Menzel’s book Flying Saucers published in Russian. Having seen through (as he later stated) the author’s dismissive rhetoric, Ziegel became intrigued by the book’s factual aspect. It reignited his old interest in all things extraterrestrial and, in retrospect, put an end to what looked like a highly promising academic career.
Cosmonautics Committee became interested enough to let the Group function under its auspieces.
Preceding this was the publication of F. Ziegel’s article in Smena Magazine where he wrote:
The article caused furore in the USSR and was noticed in the West - in fact, seen there as the first ever evidence that the Soviets were aware of the UFO phenomena too.
By this time Ziegel completed his section in the book called Naselyonny Kosmos (The Inhabited Cosmos) where he compiled a huge bulk of data collected over the three years, including numerous Russian pilots’ reports drawn from the Ministry of Civil Aviation archives. The work on it was started in 1963 by the team of well-known Soviet scientists. The extensive, ambitious volume devoted entirely to the question of extraterrestrial intelligence search was due to be released by the USSR Academy of Science’s Nauka Publishing House in 1968. The project’s Editor-in-chief was B. P. Konstantinov, the Academy’s vice-President, famous academics V. Ginzburg
, A. Blagonravov, V. Parin heading the team of scientific reviewers.
In order to promote the book and get the informational flow a boost, on November 10, 1967 Stolyarov and Ziegel went on air and, speaking on the Central TV, encouraged viewers to send first-hand accounts in. The response was astonishing: it showed, Ziegel later wrote, that the UFO phenomena was indeed widespread. But before the Committee (by this time comprising more than 200 scientists and high-level professionals) could even begin to work on the information received, it’s work was abruptly and without much explanation cancelled. To Ziegel this was a heavy blow.
In the end of 1967 the Soviet Academy of Sciences' Physics department led by L. Artsymovich, passed a resolution denouncing studying of UFOs as such. Nevertheless, in February 1968 a representative discussion was held in Moscow, academics Leontovich, Mustel and Petrov attending, Ziegel making the report. In a few days time he received a letter from Edward Condon
, director of the University of Colorado
UFO Project, suggesting that the Soviet and the American groups should cooperate, beginning with the information exchange. Figuring that such a cooperation would be possible only on the official level, Ziegel and twelve other members of his group wrote a letter to the Soviet government to make an official request for creating the state-sponsored organization that should coordinate all the UFO research in the country. Next month he received the official response: it was negative.
The Inhabited Cosmos book was already in print, when sudden B. Konstantinov’s death in July 1969 made the whole thing’s prospects bleak. Academic L. Artzymovich
instantly demanded that the book should be immediately confiscated and be brought before academic V. Fesenkov
for further scrutiny. In May 1970 almanac’s two editors, Ziegel and V. Pekelis, received by post a resume signed by Artzymovich and Fesenkov. It said among other things: "Along with articles based on strong scientific evidence we found there some pseudo-scientific scoops (UFOs, Tunguska meteorite, etc) more akin to fables, which can in no way be published under the Academy’s guidance".
Ziegel and Pekelis made an official protest. It was upheld by academic V. Parin, the almanac’s new Editor-in-Chief, but rejected by M. D. Millionschikov, the Academy’s vice-president. All in all, 32 pieces were cut. The 1972 edition, according to AиФ
, "shook the general readers profoundly" but there was not a mention in it of the UFOs and Tunguska event. "Our efforts to introduce the truth about UFO phenomena to a wide scientific community failed completely", Ziegel later admitted.
In the early 1973 I. F. Obraztsov, the then MAI rector (later – the Education minister of RSFSR
) asked Ziegel to give him a general picture of (as he put it) "the current situation around the UFO problem and suggest scientific methods of resolving it". Impressed by researcher’s report, he reacted sympathetically to the idea of re-starting the project, but when it came to providing organizational help, could promise only moral support. His letters to the Academy of Sciences
President M. Keldysh
and the governmental Science & Technology committee having brought no response, Ziegel decided to take another course of action. He called the special meeting of Academy’s Radio astronomy Council, with venerable scientists like V. S. Troitsky and N. S. Kardashev
being among those present. Ziegel’s lecture made an impact: in a carefully worded resolution the Council proposed that the "data exchange process should be maintained" between the radioastronomers' Council and the UFO investigators.
As a result in the late 1974 Ziegel formed another UFO Study Group, this time based in MAI. He compiled a major study called "The Preliminary Study of anomalies in Earth’s atmosphere" and initiated the ambitious UFO-77 symposium, 20 reports having been already prepared. All this time Ziegel continued his public lecturing; this was to be the cause of his next major trouble.
In July 1976 one of Ziegel's lectures, made in the secret Moscow Kulon plant (and, as he later made point to stress, KGB
-sanctioned), amateurishly shorthanded and full of mistakes (but bearing the author’s – name, credentials and even home telephone number), appeared in samizdat
. What followed Ziegel later referred to as his ‘days of nightmare’. His phones at home and in MAI were ringing continuously, driving him to the point of nervous breakdown. Detractors saw their chance. On November 28, 1976 sci-fi writer Yeremey Parnov
published in Komsomolskaya Pravda
an article entitled "The Technology of Myth-mongering". Referring directly to Ziegel and his studies, he called for "this whole UFO business to be sorted out", labeling ufology as 'pseudoscience'. Ziegel, who always made the point of conducting his research on strictly scientific basis, responded by "The Technology of Lie" article but none of the central press wanted to publish it. Ziegel tried to sue Parnov for libel, but, as he later said, "in those times such a thing was all but impossible".
Ziegel’s UFO Study group was disbanded, the 1977 symposium cancelled. What Ziegel saw as “the libeling campaign aimed at the UFO studies as a whole”, commenced. Not only MAI authorities lost all interest in the UFOs, but what they did was open a 'Ziegel’s case', forming two commissions aimed at 're-evaluating' him and his work. While one of them found Ziegel's professional activities in the institute flawless, another took a deeper approach, involving studies of his family history, notably his parents' pre-1917 "behavior". According to this second commission's verdict, Ziegel’s work was non-scientific and entirely ‘self-promotional’, it’s motivation being "getting the West interested in his own persona".
According to commissions’ joint communiqué, Ziegel’s mistakes were the result of his "poor knowledge of the principal postulates of Marxism-Leninism
", which prompted him "taking upon the subject far beyond his scientific qualification and scope of knowledge". Researcher’s demand for this verdict to be openly discussed at the institute’s Communist party committee was left unresponded. Ziegel, though, has had, apparently, some (unspecified) influential allies. In The Brief History of the UFO Studying in the USSR he wrote:
Indeed, it was only from the Obshestvo Znaniye ('Knowledge' Society) that had been employing him as lecturer for more than thirty years, that he was expelled. Otherwise Ziegel’s professional career at MAI continued as if nothing happened. Detractors had other ideas about his future. Among Ziegel’s harshest critics were physicists V. A. Lashkovtsev and B. N. Panovkin (his former student). And, of course, - "Y. I. Parnov was not to be left behind. As A. P. Kazantsev informed me, speaking at the Writers’ Union special Science fiction authors’ congress on February 23, 1977, Yeremei Iudovich insisted that ‘Ziegel’s lectures were the act of foreign ideological subversion. Their direct result was our industry’s labour efficiency 40 per cent drop’!", Ziegel wrote.
Despite all this, in 1979 he managed to form another group of the UFO investigation enthusiasts. The group was unofficial and functioned under different conspiratorial guises, almost underground. It compiled, though, 13 type-written volumes of classified UFO sightings’ evidence, complete with fresh theoretical works: studies on new methodics and original theories concerning the possible nature of the phenomena, all summed up in the extensive thesis entitled The Introduction to the Future UFO Theory.
T. F. Konstantinova-Ziegel held no doubts as for his death having been the result of heavy stress that had been dogging Ziegel for decades. Speaking to AиФ in March 2010, she said:
According to ufology.net at least 50,000 UFO reports collected by Ziegel were storaged in the MAI computers. T. F. Konstantinova-Ziegel claims she is still in a possession of 17 huge type-written volumes of her father’s unpublished work.
Docent
Docent is a title at some European universities to denote a specific academic appointment within a set structure of academic ranks below professor . Docent is also used at some universities generically for a person who has the right to teach...
of Cosmology
Cosmology
Cosmology is the discipline that deals with the nature of the Universe as a whole. Cosmologists seek to understand the origin, evolution, structure, and ultimate fate of the Universe at large, as well as the natural laws that keep it in order...
at the Moscow Aviation Institute
Moscow Aviation Institute
Moscow Aviation Institute is one of several major engineering higher education establishments in Moscow .Although the school is currently offering a wide range of majors and research...
, author of more than 40 popular books on astronomy
Astronomy
Astronomy is a natural science that deals with the study of celestial objects and phenomena that originate outside the atmosphere of Earth...
and space exploration, generally regarded as a founder of Russia
Russia
Russia or , officially known as both Russia and the Russian Federation , is a country in northern Eurasia. It is a federal semi-presidential republic, comprising 83 federal subjects...
n ufology
Ufology
Ufology is a neologism coined to describe the collective efforts of those who study reports and associated evidence of unidentified flying objects . UFOs have been subject to various investigations over the years by governments, independent groups, and scientists...
. Ziegel, co-organizer of the first ever officially approved Soviet UFO studying group, became an overnight sensation when, on November 10, 1967, speaking on the Soviet central television, he made an extensive report on the UFO sightings registered in the USSR and encouraged viewers to send him and his colleagues first-hand accounts of their observations, which resulted in barrage of letters and reports. Having lost the final of his many battles with detractors in 1976, Ziegel continued his studies unofficially. He died in November 1988, 17 massive volumes of his vast research legacy remaining in his daughter's archives, unpublished.
Biography
Felix Ziegel was born on March 20, 1920, son of a lawyer, Yury Konstantinovich Ziegel, a Russian-born ethnic GermanGermans
The Germans are a Germanic ethnic group native to Central Europe. The English term Germans has referred to the German-speaking population of the Holy Roman Empire since the Late Middle Ages....
. Ziegel often spoke (as his daughter wrote in her memoirs) of how he’d begin his future autobiography with the words: "I was sentenced to death before I was even born". Indeed, in March 1920 Yury Ziegel’s 22-year old wife, Nadezhda Platonovna, was on the Cheka
Cheka
Cheka was the first of a succession of Soviet state security organizations. It was created by a decree issued on December 20, 1917, by Vladimir Lenin and subsequently led by aristocrat-turned-communist Felix Dzerzhinsky...
’s death row, waiting to be put before the firing squad for alleged ‘counter-revolutionary activities’. In the unlikeliest turn of events (as her grand-daughter later wrote) the sight of a 'doomed young beauty in her last days of pregnancy' made so disturbing an effect on a senior investigator officer that what he did was promptly open the door and let her go. One week after her miraculous release Nadezhda Ziegel gave birth to her son. The parents called him Felix, although not after Dzerzhinsky, the infamous ‘iron man’ of the early Soviet revolutionary justice, as some of the family’s friends half-seriously suggested. It was Prince Felix Yusupov
Felix Yusupov
Prince Felix Felixovich Yusupov, Count Sumarokov-Elston , was best known for participating in the murder of Grigori Rasputin, the faith healer who was said to have influenced decisions of Tsar Nicholas II and Tsaritsa Alexandra Feodorovna.-Biography:...
, the man behind the notorious Rasputin murder, whom husband and wife hero-worshipped, praising his ‘patriotism and unique courage’.
Felix Ziegel, born a weak and sickly child, was sent to the family's countryside dacha
Dacha
Dacha is a Russian word for seasonal or year-round second homes often located in the exurbs of Soviet and post-Soviet cities. Cottages or shacks serving as family's main or only home are not considered dachas, although many purpose-built dachas are recently being converted for year-round residence...
in Tarusa
Tarusa
Tarusa is a town and the administrative center of Tarussky District of Kaluga Oblast, Russia, located on the left bank of the Oka River, south of Serpukhov, northeast of Kaluga, and about south of Moscow. Population:...
to be there literally milked back to life. It was here in Tarusa that a six year old constructed his first primitive telescope
Telescope
A telescope is an instrument that aids in the observation of remote objects by collecting electromagnetic radiation . The first known practical telescopes were invented in the Netherlands at the beginning of the 1600s , using glass lenses...
and started his first journal of astronomical observations. Regardless of the post-1917 hardships, Yuri Ziegel managed to give his son fine education, both technical and humanitarian. Young Felix, apart from being a fanatical astronomy enthusiast, showed deep interest in (and later - academic level knowledge of) history, philosophy
Philosophy
Philosophy is the study of general and fundamental problems, such as those connected with existence, knowledge, values, reason, mind, and language. Philosophy is distinguished from other ways of addressing such problems by its critical, generally systematic approach and its reliance on rational...
, Russian Orthodox Church
Russian Orthodox Church
The Russian Orthodox Church or, alternatively, the Moscow Patriarchate The ROC is often said to be the largest of the Eastern Orthodox churches in the world; including all the autocephalous churches under its umbrella, its adherents number over 150 million worldwide—about half of the 300 million...
architecture and theology
Theology
Theology is the systematic and rational study of religion and its influences and of the nature of religious truths, or the learned profession acquired by completing specialized training in religious studies, usually at a university or school of divinity or seminary.-Definition:Augustine of Hippo...
, the family being a very religious one. In fact, influenced by his spiritual tutor, Alexandr Vvedensky
Alexander Vvedensky (religious leader)
Alexandr Ivanovich Vvedensky was one of the leaders of the Living Church movement , a movement of the Russian Orthodox Church from 1922-1946 to reform the Russian Church life; he is considered the person...
, whose sermons he attended regularly, Felix seriously considered the possibility of devoting himself to religion. Love for astronomy prevailed, though, and in 1938 he joined the Moscow University’s Mekhmat (Mechanics & mathematics) faculty.
Two years earlier 16 year old Felix Ziegel took part in his first ever scientific expedition: along with the team of senior scientists he traveled to Kazahstan to observe the total eclipse
Eclipse
An eclipse is an astronomical event that occurs when an astronomical object is temporarily obscured, either by passing into the shadow of another body or by having another body pass between it and the viewer...
of the Sun
Sun
The Sun is the star at the center of the Solar System. It is almost perfectly spherical and consists of hot plasma interwoven with magnetic fields...
. It was there that Ziegel - in the case of rare coincidence - got acquainted with a member of an US expedition camped nearside. The name of the American was Donald Howard Menzel
Donald Howard Menzel
Donald Howard Menzel was one of the first theoretical astronomers and astrophysicists in the US. He discovered the physical properties of the solar chromosphere, the chemistry of stars, the atmosphere of Mars, and the nature of gaseous neblulae.-Biography:Born in Florence, Colorado in 1901 and...
, the one whose book some years later would change his whole life.
In 1939 Felix Ziegel, a 2nd year student, was expelled from the University, the reason being his father’s arrest for allegedly plotting the destruction a factory in Tambov
Tambov
Tambov is a city and the administrative center of Tambov Oblast, Russia, located at the confluence of the Tsna and Studenets Rivers southeast of Moscow...
. It soon transpired that the anonymous report was compiled by a neighbour, motivated by the prospect of moving into the jailed man’s flat. Yuri Ziegel was freed, but not until he spent two years in prison. According to Tatyana, his grand-daughter, Ziegel-senior returned a physically and morally broken man. His leg had to be amputated – a direct consequence of so-called zhuravl (the Crane) torture which involved causing a prisoner to stand on one leg during the interrogation.
In 1941, as the war broke out, Ziegels were deported to Alma-Ata. That was taken as a kind of favour, almost, since Felix, as an ethnic German, might have ended up easily in a labour camp or the much feared shtrafbat ranks. Soon he even managed to return to the University which he was graduated from in 1945. The same year his first book "Eclipses of the Moon" was published. In 1948 after three years’ work in the USSR Academy of Science F. Ziegel has got his Doctor of Sciences' Сanditate degree (in astronomy) and started lecturing in Moscow institutes.
In the late 1940s Ziegel made his debut as a public lecturer, speaking mostly in Moscow's Geodesic institute and The Planetarium, to a hugely favourable popular response. Ziegel's Life on Mars
Mars
Mars is the fourth planet from the Sun in the Solar System. The planet is named after the Roman god of war, Mars. It is often described as the "Red Planet", as the iron oxide prevalent on its surface gives it a reddish appearance...
and Tunguska
Tunguska event
The Tunguska event, or Tunguska blast or Tunguska explosion, was an enormously powerful explosion that occurred near the Podkamennaya Tunguska River in what is now Krasnoyarsk Krai, Russia, at about 7:14 a.m...
spoken-word shows were all-round favourites; one-kilometer queus of avid ticket-buyers stretched out to the venues. Ziegel’s lectures were staged in the manner of modernist theater pieces. The Tunguska show, based on the Alexander Kazantsev
Alexander Kazantsev
Alexander Petrovitch Kazantsev was a popular Soviet science fiction writer and ufologist.-Biography:Born in Akmolinsk, Imperial Russia . He graduated from Tomsk Polytechnic University, and worked in Soviet Research institute of Electromechanics. Kazantsev was a member of Soviet delegation at the...
’s sci-fi short story Vzryv (The Blast) had a soldier protagonist played by a professional actor; the latter sauntered all around the place, theoreticising about how Tunguska disaster might have been the result of an atom bomb explosion akin to that of Hiroshima
Hiroshima
is the capital of Hiroshima Prefecture, and the largest city in the Chūgoku region of western Honshu, the largest island of Japan. It became best known as the first city in history to be destroyed by a nuclear weapon when the United States Army Air Forces dropped an atomic bomb on it at 8:15 A.M...
or an alien spacecraft crash, enthralled audience members gradually being involved into a discussion.
Indeed, it was Ziegel who put forward the first ever mathematically justified hypothesis for Tunguska blast having been the result of an alien spacecraft crash (which, according to the author, made a curve-like maneuver 600 kilometers in diameter before exploding in the air). The concept jarred with the official ‘meteorite theory’ but a decade later the evidence was found proving the object indeed went off in the air, without contacting the Earth. The discovery was a result of numerous expeditions to the region in the 1960s made by enthusiasts who, in their own turn, cited early Ziegel's lectures as an original inspiration.
In 1963 Ziegel, now a co-author (with V. P. Burdakov) of the first ever Soviet university textbook on cosmonautics and space exploration became the astronomy docent in the Moscow Aviation Institute
Moscow Aviation Institute
Moscow Aviation Institute is one of several major engineering higher education establishments in Moscow .Although the school is currently offering a wide range of majors and research...
. The same year he read Donald Menzel’s book Flying Saucers published in Russian. Having seen through (as he later stated) the author’s dismissive rhetoric, Ziegel became intrigued by the book’s factual aspect. It reignited his old interest in all things extraterrestrial and, in retrospect, put an end to what looked like a highly promising academic career.
F. Y. Ziegel and the UFO studies
In the early 1967 the first official Soviet UFO Study Group was formed. Its first meeting was held on May 17, 1967 in the Moscow ЦДАиК (Aviation and Cosmonautics Center). Major-general P. A. Stolyarov was the group's leader, F. Ziegel his first deputy. In October The DOSAAFDOSAAF
DOSAAF was a paramilitary society in the Soviet Union, Voluntary Society for Cooperation with the Army, Aviation, and Fleet . The society was preserved in a number of post-Soviet Republics, e.g., in Russia and Belarus...
Cosmonautics Committee became interested enough to let the Group function under its auspieces.
Preceding this was the publication of F. Ziegel’s article in Smena Magazine where he wrote:
The article caused furore in the USSR and was noticed in the West - in fact, seen there as the first ever evidence that the Soviets were aware of the UFO phenomena too.
By this time Ziegel completed his section in the book called Naselyonny Kosmos (The Inhabited Cosmos) where he compiled a huge bulk of data collected over the three years, including numerous Russian pilots’ reports drawn from the Ministry of Civil Aviation archives. The work on it was started in 1963 by the team of well-known Soviet scientists. The extensive, ambitious volume devoted entirely to the question of extraterrestrial intelligence search was due to be released by the USSR Academy of Science’s Nauka Publishing House in 1968. The project’s Editor-in-chief was B. P. Konstantinov, the Academy’s vice-President, famous academics V. Ginzburg
Vitaly Ginzburg
Vitaly Lazarevich Ginzburg ForMemRS was a Soviet theoretical physicist, astrophysicist, Nobel laureate, a member of the Russian Academy of Sciences and one of the fathers of Soviet hydrogen bomb...
, A. Blagonravov, V. Parin heading the team of scientific reviewers.
In order to promote the book and get the informational flow a boost, on November 10, 1967 Stolyarov and Ziegel went on air and, speaking on the Central TV, encouraged viewers to send first-hand accounts in. The response was astonishing: it showed, Ziegel later wrote, that the UFO phenomena was indeed widespread. But before the Committee (by this time comprising more than 200 scientists and high-level professionals) could even begin to work on the information received, it’s work was abruptly and without much explanation cancelled. To Ziegel this was a heavy blow.
In the end of 1967 the Soviet Academy of Sciences' Physics department led by L. Artsymovich, passed a resolution denouncing studying of UFOs as such. Nevertheless, in February 1968 a representative discussion was held in Moscow, academics Leontovich, Mustel and Petrov attending, Ziegel making the report. In a few days time he received a letter from Edward Condon
Edward Condon
Edward Uhler Condon was a distinguished American nuclear physicist, a pioneer in quantum mechanics, and a participant in the development of radar and nuclear weapons during World War II.-Early life and career:...
, director of the University of Colorado
University of Colorado at Boulder
The University of Colorado Boulder is a public research university located in Boulder, Colorado...
UFO Project, suggesting that the Soviet and the American groups should cooperate, beginning with the information exchange. Figuring that such a cooperation would be possible only on the official level, Ziegel and twelve other members of his group wrote a letter to the Soviet government to make an official request for creating the state-sponsored organization that should coordinate all the UFO research in the country. Next month he received the official response: it was negative.
The Inhabited Cosmos book was already in print, when sudden B. Konstantinov’s death in July 1969 made the whole thing’s prospects bleak. Academic L. Artzymovich
Lev Artsimovich
Lev Andreevich Artsimovich was a Soviet physicist, academician of the Soviet Academy of Sciences , member of the Presidium of the Soviet Academy of Sciences , and Hero of Socialist Labor .- Academic research :Artsimovich worked on the...
instantly demanded that the book should be immediately confiscated and be brought before academic V. Fesenkov
Vasily Fesenkov
Vasiliy Grigorievich Fesenkov was a Soviet Russian astrophysicist.-Biography:He was born in Novocherkassk. After graduating from the Kharkov University he entered the Sorbonne, where he defended a dissertation for the Doctor of Science degree in 1914. Fesenkov was one of founders of the Russian...
for further scrutiny. In May 1970 almanac’s two editors, Ziegel and V. Pekelis, received by post a resume signed by Artzymovich and Fesenkov. It said among other things: "Along with articles based on strong scientific evidence we found there some pseudo-scientific scoops (UFOs, Tunguska meteorite, etc) more akin to fables, which can in no way be published under the Academy’s guidance".
Ziegel and Pekelis made an official protest. It was upheld by academic V. Parin, the almanac’s new Editor-in-Chief, but rejected by M. D. Millionschikov, the Academy’s vice-president. All in all, 32 pieces were cut. The 1972 edition, according to AиФ
Argumenty i fakty
Argumenty i Fakty is a weekly newspaper based in Moscow and a publishing house in Russia and worldwide. As of 2008, it is owned by Promsvyazbank and the newspaper is edited by Nikolay Zyatkov.- History :...
, "shook the general readers profoundly" but there was not a mention in it of the UFOs and Tunguska event. "Our efforts to introduce the truth about UFO phenomena to a wide scientific community failed completely", Ziegel later admitted.
In the early 1973 I. F. Obraztsov, the then MAI rector (later – the Education minister of RSFSR
Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic
The Russian Soviet Federative Socialist Republic , commonly referred to as Soviet Russia, Bolshevik Russia, or simply Russia, was the largest, most populous and economically developed republic in the former Soviet Union....
) asked Ziegel to give him a general picture of (as he put it) "the current situation around the UFO problem and suggest scientific methods of resolving it". Impressed by researcher’s report, he reacted sympathetically to the idea of re-starting the project, but when it came to providing organizational help, could promise only moral support. His letters to the Academy of Sciences
Russian Academy of Sciences
The Russian Academy of Sciences consists of the national academy of Russia and a network of scientific research institutes from across the Russian Federation as well as auxiliary scientific and social units like libraries, publishers and hospitals....
President M. Keldysh
Mstislav Keldysh
Mstislav Vsevolodovich Keldysh was a Soviet scientist in the field of mathematics and mechanics, academician of the USSR Academy of Sciences , President of the USSR Academy of Sciences , three times Hero of Socialist Labor , fellow of the Royal Society of Edinburgh . He was one of the key figures...
and the governmental Science & Technology committee having brought no response, Ziegel decided to take another course of action. He called the special meeting of Academy’s Radio astronomy Council, with venerable scientists like V. S. Troitsky and N. S. Kardashev
Nikolai Kardashev
Nikolai Semenovich Kardashev is a Russian astrophysicist, and is the deputy director of the Russian Space Research Institute of the Russian Academy of Sciences in Moscow.Kardashev graduated from Moscow State University in 1955, following up at...
being among those present. Ziegel’s lecture made an impact: in a carefully worded resolution the Council proposed that the "data exchange process should be maintained" between the radioastronomers' Council and the UFO investigators.
As a result in the late 1974 Ziegel formed another UFO Study Group, this time based in MAI. He compiled a major study called "The Preliminary Study of anomalies in Earth’s atmosphere" and initiated the ambitious UFO-77 symposium, 20 reports having been already prepared. All this time Ziegel continued his public lecturing; this was to be the cause of his next major trouble.
In July 1976 one of Ziegel's lectures, made in the secret Moscow Kulon plant (and, as he later made point to stress, KGB
KGB
The KGB was the commonly used acronym for the . It was the national security agency of the Soviet Union from 1954 until 1991, and was the premier internal security, intelligence, and secret police organization during that time.The State Security Agency of the Republic of Belarus currently uses the...
-sanctioned), amateurishly shorthanded and full of mistakes (but bearing the author’s – name, credentials and even home telephone number), appeared in samizdat
Samizdat
Samizdat was a key form of dissident activity across the Soviet bloc in which individuals reproduced censored publications by hand and passed the documents from reader to reader...
. What followed Ziegel later referred to as his ‘days of nightmare’. His phones at home and in MAI were ringing continuously, driving him to the point of nervous breakdown. Detractors saw their chance. On November 28, 1976 sci-fi writer Yeremey Parnov
Yeremey Parnov
Yeremey Iudovich Parnov was a Soviet and Russian writer and publicist. Parnov attended the Moscow Peat University and worked as a Chemical Engineer. He also used to work as a professional journalist...
published in Komsomolskaya Pravda
Komsomolskaya Pravda
Komsomolskaya Pravda is a daily Russian tabloid newspaper, founded on March 13th, 1925. It is published by "Izdatelsky Dom Komsomolskaya Pravda" .- History :...
an article entitled "The Technology of Myth-mongering". Referring directly to Ziegel and his studies, he called for "this whole UFO business to be sorted out", labeling ufology as 'pseudoscience'. Ziegel, who always made the point of conducting his research on strictly scientific basis, responded by "The Technology of Lie" article but none of the central press wanted to publish it. Ziegel tried to sue Parnov for libel, but, as he later said, "in those times such a thing was all but impossible".
Ziegel’s UFO Study group was disbanded, the 1977 symposium cancelled. What Ziegel saw as “the libeling campaign aimed at the UFO studies as a whole”, commenced. Not only MAI authorities lost all interest in the UFOs, but what they did was open a 'Ziegel’s case', forming two commissions aimed at 're-evaluating' him and his work. While one of them found Ziegel's professional activities in the institute flawless, another took a deeper approach, involving studies of his family history, notably his parents' pre-1917 "behavior". According to this second commission's verdict, Ziegel’s work was non-scientific and entirely ‘self-promotional’, it’s motivation being "getting the West interested in his own persona".
According to commissions’ joint communiqué, Ziegel’s mistakes were the result of his "poor knowledge of the principal postulates of Marxism-Leninism
Marxism-Leninism
Marxism–Leninism is a communist ideology, officially based upon the theories of Marxism and Vladimir Lenin, that promotes the development and creation of a international communist society through the leadership of a vanguard party over a revolutionary socialist state that represents a dictatorship...
", which prompted him "taking upon the subject far beyond his scientific qualification and scope of knowledge". Researcher’s demand for this verdict to be openly discussed at the institute’s Communist party committee was left unresponded. Ziegel, though, has had, apparently, some (unspecified) influential allies. In The Brief History of the UFO Studying in the USSR he wrote:
...So I had to forward letters to our country’s highest quarters. In them I wrote about how important it was that the UFOs should be studied in the USSR, of how serious and significant this problem was and of this press campaign’s sheer absurdity. And this time my voice has been heard. These higher quarters interfered and made sure no repressive sanctions would be put against me.
Indeed, it was only from the Obshestvo Znaniye ('Knowledge' Society) that had been employing him as lecturer for more than thirty years, that he was expelled. Otherwise Ziegel’s professional career at MAI continued as if nothing happened. Detractors had other ideas about his future. Among Ziegel’s harshest critics were physicists V. A. Lashkovtsev and B. N. Panovkin (his former student). And, of course, - "Y. I. Parnov was not to be left behind. As A. P. Kazantsev informed me, speaking at the Writers’ Union special Science fiction authors’ congress on February 23, 1977, Yeremei Iudovich insisted that ‘Ziegel’s lectures were the act of foreign ideological subversion. Their direct result was our industry’s labour efficiency 40 per cent drop’!", Ziegel wrote.
Despite all this, in 1979 he managed to form another group of the UFO investigation enthusiasts. The group was unofficial and functioned under different conspiratorial guises, almost underground. It compiled, though, 13 type-written volumes of classified UFO sightings’ evidence, complete with fresh theoretical works: studies on new methodics and original theories concerning the possible nature of the phenomena, all summed up in the extensive thesis entitled The Introduction to the Future UFO Theory.
Ziegel's death
It all ended in 1985 when Ziegel suffered his first stroke. Once back on his feet, he returned to the institute full of ideas and lecturing plans, but those would remain unfulfilled. Felix Ziegel died of his second stroke on November 20, 1988.T. F. Konstantinova-Ziegel held no doubts as for his death having been the result of heavy stress that had been dogging Ziegel for decades. Speaking to AиФ in March 2010, she said:
For father Stalinism was a never ending affair. As the War broke out he, an ethnic German, had to be deported to Alma-Ata. After the War he had difficulties because his second name sounded too Jewish to many. And in the years of Thaw, when the whole country started to shake itself off this horrible catatonia, in science the domination of 'the one and only correct point of view' was still regarded a norm. Obscurantism and common ignorance, unveiled malice from one group of people and secret jealousy of another – those were the reasons that prevented him from bringing his ideas to the general public's awareness.
According to ufology.net at least 50,000 UFO reports collected by Ziegel were storaged in the MAI computers. T. F. Konstantinova-Ziegel claims she is still in a possession of 17 huge type-written volumes of her father’s unpublished work.